ZANZIBAR –
Here’s an odd prediction for the coming year: 2013 will be a watershed for
financial reform. True, while the global financial crisis erupted more than
four years ago, and the Dodd-Frank financial reforms were adopted in the United
States back in 2010, not much has changed
about how Wall Street operates – except that the large firms have become bigger
and more powerful. Yet there are reasons to expect real progress in the new
year.

The US Federal Reserve is finally shifting its thinking. In a series of
major speeches this fall, Governor Dan Tarullo made the case that the problem
of “too big to fail” financial institutions remains with us. We need to take
additional measures to reduce the level of systemic risk – including limiting
the size of our largest banks. News reports indicate that the Fed has already started
saying no to some bank mergers.
At the same time, the US Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation has become a
bastion of sensible thinking on financial-sector issues. In part, this is
because the FDIC is responsible for cleaning up the mess when financial-sector
firms fail, so its senior officials have a strong incentive to protect its
insurance fund by preventing risks from getting out of control. The FDIC is
showing intellectual leadership as well as organizational capabilities – Vice
Chairman Tom Hoenig’s speeches are a
must-read.
Wall Street is pushing back, of course. But the rolling series of scandals
surrounding global megabanks makes it difficult for anyone to keep a straight
face when executives insist that our largest banks must maintain their current
scale and scope. Do we need HSBC to facilitate global money laundering? Do we
need Barclays and UBS to manipulate Libor (a key benchmark for interest rates
around the world)? Do we need still more losses at poorly run trading
operations for JP Morgan Chase?
The pro-bank lobby groups are positioning themselves to argue that the new
resolution powers under Dodd-Frank have ended the too-big-to-fail problem, and
we can expect a public-relations drive in this direction early in the new year.
But the consensus view at the
most recent meeting of the FDIC’s Systemic Resolution
Advisory Committee (of which I am a member) was that this claim should not be
taken seriously. Under Dodd-Frank, it is arguably easier for the FDIC to handle
the failure of a single large financial institution than it was in
pre-Dodd-Frank days. But what if two or three or seven firms are all in trouble
at the same time?
The answer, as former Fed Chairman Paul Volcker implied at the meeting, is
that we would be right back where we started – in the panic and frozen credit
markets that followed the collapse of Lehman Brothers in September 2008.
Indeed, the idea that substantial shocks could soon hit the US
financial system is not far-fetched. The European debt crisis, for example,
remains far from being resolved. A significant sovereign-debt restructuring
there would bring down European banks and potentially damage US banks – as well
as financial institutions around the world.
Meanwhile, the continuing problems at European banks are a stark reminder
that operating highly leveraged, thinly capitalized firms is incredibly risky.
And the regulatory failures in Europe – consider the
German Landesbanks, for example – will become only more obvious in the coming
months. Creating a common supervisory authority will mean nothing unless it can
clean up the mess created by the existing supervisors. And that cleanup will
expose more of the rot in banks’ current operations.
The need for banks to finance themselves with more equity and relatively
less debt will be the focus of one of the main publishing events in economics
in 2013. Anat Admati and Martin Hellwig’s
The Bankers’ New Clothes:
What’s Wrong with Banking and What to Do About it? will appear
officially in March, but advance copies are already being closely read in
leading central banks. Bankers everywhere will rush to read it before their
regulators do.
The road to the ongoing financial and economic crisis was built on a
foundation of intellectual capture: not only regulators, but academics, too,
became captivated by modern finance and its methods. Admati and Hellwig are at
the vanguard of the counterrevolution, challenging the great myths of banking
head-on.
Do we need financial institutions to be so highly leveraged (that is,
carrying so much debt relative to equity)? No, they argue. If banks of all
kinds were financed with more equity, they would have stronger buffers to
absorb losses. Both the equity and the debt issued by well-capitalized banks
would be safer – and therefore cheaper.
Bankers want to be so highly leveraged for a simple reason: implicit
government guarantees mean that they get the upside when things go well, while
the downside is someone else’s problem. Contrary to bankers’ claims, this is
not a good arrangement for society.
Admati and Hellwig are confronting the bankers and their allies in no
uncertain terms, grounding their argument in deep financial thinking, yet
writing for a broad audience. Whatever else happens in 2013, we can be sure
that they will not win the Goldman Sachs Business Book of the Year award.
Simon Johnson, a former chief
economist of the IMF, is a professor at MIT Sloan, a senior fellow at the
Peterson Institute for International Economics, and co-founder of a leading
economics blog, The
Baseline Scenario. He is the co-author, with James Kwak, of White House Burning: The
Founding Fathers, Our National Debt, and Why It Matters to You.