陳雲草擬：用英文向外國人解釋簡體字及普通話的弊端

近年愈來愈多香港商店及公司在公共空間展示中共簡體字告示及廣告，污染香港文化，破壞一國兩制。以下的聲明，可以用來撰寫英文投訴信，向外國人 解釋，或向香港的公共機構用英文投訴，使西人高層明白到簡體字侵犯香港的文化權利，也是危害世上碩果僅存的漢字保育區。也請廣傳予關心香港的國際社會或學 習中文的外國人知道。

Stop Using Simplified Chinese Characters in Public Notices and Signboards. Help Conserve the Endangered Orthodox Chinese Language in Hong Kong

The simplified Chinese writing system was created in the 1950s and imposed upon the Chinese public by the communist government of China through legislation, media control and publication laws. The set of simplified characters were derived from popular shorthands and synonyms or designed by government linguists. The changes made are analogous to merging such syllables as "key-", "quay-", "kea-", "cay-" and "kee-" into “ki-”, spreading it through the press and the education system, and then banning the original spellings from all public spaces.

The simplified Chinese writing system was created largely without regard to the expressiveness and structural aesthetics of Chinese characters in use since the Han dynasty (206 BC -220AD). The cultured consider it a crude set of shorthands. Most linguists outside Mainland China consider it a political tool for cutting the link of Chinese people from their historical roots, rendering historical accounts and ancient literature confusing if not incomprehensible, just as Shakespeare would appear if it were littered with “thru”, “ki” and the like.

Hong Kong and Taiwan are two major Chinese societies that use the orthodox Chinese writing system and free from direct communist rule (so far!). Hong Kongers (and their neighbours from Macau) speak Cantonese whose metre is close to their ancestors' in the Tang dynasty a millenium ago. But same as the mainlanders, the Taiwanese people speak Mandarin ("Putonghua"), which is a form of spoken Chinese mixed with Mongolian and Manchu languages in the recent dynasties. If you don't know what that means, imagine Britain being taken over by invaders and the English word “thrust” considered too difficult and thus "reduced" to “fuss”.

That is to say, Hong Kong is the only place in the world that preserves both orthodox spoken Chinese and written Chinese. Yet some shops and organizations have started to use simplified Chinese in public signboards and instructions in reaction to the influx of tourists from China. We ask these shops and organisations to switch back to orthodox Chinese as a respect to the endangered languages of Hong Kong. In fact, Mainland Chinese tourists do read traditional Chinese, sometimes with the help of contextual cues and intelligent guessing, as it has always been.

( 混沌:        The introduction and enforcement of simplified Chinese forms had many drawbacks which were noted by the Language Committee shortly after its implementation. The main premise behind the whole policy is the fewer number of strokes in each word would enhance the learning of the illiterate and boosted the literacy rate. However, the committee was quickly aware of the confusion and the complete severance from the traditional Chinese characters creation logic would ultimately be a disaster, like a simplified word would represent more than one traditional forms, and sometimes the simplified form is a traditional word as well. This has a detrimental effect on the way people read, they would have to read the whole sentence before knowing what the words actually mean, sometimes the confusion remains even after finishing the whole paragraph. Further reading:陳雲:香港文字學系列(一))